[VA] What is the correct order for filing motions to stay an unlawful detainer eviction on appeal?

VA Landlord-Tenant

Legal Eagle

135,460 satisfied customers

View context

Solved

Let's break down your situation and the steps you can take:

Motion to Stay Unlawful Detainer Pending Federal Appeal — this motion is used to pause the eviction process while your federal appeal is being considered. It's different from a stay for modification, which seeks to change the terms of an existing order. You should file this motion if your appeal is still pending and you want to halt the eviction process. Virginia's appeal statute, Va. Code § 8.01-129, governs how an appeal from a general district court's unlawful detainer judgment is perfected in circuit court, including the timing and security requirements involved.
Motion to Reduce or Waive Escrow/Bond — if the bond amount is unaffordable, you can file this motion to request the court to lower or eliminate the bond required to stay the eviction. This is crucial if you cannot afford the $3,700 bond. Under Va. Code § 16.1-107, a defendant found to be indigent generally is not required to post an appeal bond, although unlawful detainer appeals involving a residential dwelling carry their own payment requirements tied to outstanding rent and related charges.
Motion to Dismiss Based on Pending Title Litigation — this motion argues that the eviction should be dismissed because there's ongoing litigation regarding the property's title. You would need to provide evidence of the pending title litigation to support this motion.
Indigency/Fee Waiver — file this request to waive court fees due to financial hardship. It's typically filed before other motions to ensure you're not burdened by costs. This can be done at the clerk's window before filing other motions. The indigency standard referenced in the bond statute above (Va. Code § 16.1-107) ties into the guidelines set out in Va. Code § 19.2-159 for determining eligibility.
Temporary Restraining Order (TRO) or Preliminary Injunction — these are legal tools that can prevent eviction from occurring until a court can make a final decision. They are usually sought after an eviction has been ordered, but you can inquire if it's applicable in your case. Since August 2024, Virginia circuit courts apply Rule 3:26 of the Rules of the Supreme Court of Virginia, which sets out the standard for granting a TRO or preliminary injunction, including the showing of irreparable harm required.
Communicate with Your Lawyer — it's important to discuss these motions with your interim lawyer, even if they initially said your motions wouldn't work. Explain your financial situation and the need for a payment plan that you can afford.

Full Conversation

Virginia unlawful detainer stay questions:

There was an April 8th trial directed from the interim lawyer regarding a motion to dismiss and stay, and he presented to the court, judge, and opposition a stay due April 15th at $3,700.00. I cannot afford that on my SSI of $812.00 a month. I am a 76 year old senior with a mental health disability.

Note: I filed an "ex parte emergency stay modification of April 15th enforcement" motion, and had not read about the other motions related to a stay.

Question I asked before on Friday: what sequence of these do I file first?

The senior legal aid worker said I should file a motion to rehear to modify the conditions. The challenge is that the motion I filed Friday and the ones I would file today in the afternoon would not be heard until this Friday, all at once, and I feel that the ones I file today will have to be presented by my interim lawyer, unless this week, when I ask for a co-counsel relationship, he withdraws. I cannot speak clearly. I have a severe stuttering condition and cannot be clear due to shyness or my mental health condition, which is like a form of Asperger's or adult autism as an example. I am embarrassed.

Here is a list of motions I was guided to file. Which one, in which order, in Fairfax County Circuit Court, Virginia, or state court?

Motion to Stay Unlawful Detainer Pending Federal Appeal: is this different from the stay for modification?

Motion to Reduce or Waive Escrow/Bond: they did not charge the bond amount yet, only $3,700, but if I do not pay on time, they charge the full back amount as a bond and process of possession.

Motion to Dismiss Based on Pending Title Litigation: what is the formal language I would use for that?

Indigency/Fee Waiver: is this the form you mean that I would pre-file at the clerk's window before all the above?

What is your guidance? This has to do with a refile of the same case involving a wrongful foreclosure. It went to federal court as a lawsuit and was dismissed because I missed a seventh note stating my anxiety, when there were six doctors' notes. It is now on appeal in the Fourth Circuit Court.

Part two: can I file a TRO or preliminary injunction in the Circuit Court of Fairfax County building, or am I correct that I keep being told that can only be done "after an eviction"?

Lexi, Chatbot

I understand that you're facing a complex legal situation, and it can be overwhelming. Can you please confirm if you have already filed any motions in the Fairfax County Circuit Court regarding your unlawful detainer case?

Yes, I filed an "ex parte emergency stay modification of April 15th enforcement" motion.

Lexi, Chatbot

Have you been able to communicate with your interim lawyer about your concerns and the motions you need to file?

Yes. He said none of my motions will work, that I got a good stay deal at the trial, when he did not ask me what I could afford to sustain or when I could start a payment plan.

Lexi, Chatbot

Is there anything else the lawyer should know before I connect you? Rest assured, they'll be able to help with your unlawful detainer stay.

You got it all.

Legal Eagle

Hey there! Welcome to our service. I'm Legal Eagle, an attorney with many years of experience, and I'm here to help you. I understand you're dealing with a complex situation involving an unlawful detainer stay and various motions in Fairfax County Circuit Court. Is that correct?

Yes.

Legal Eagle

Based on your situation, there are several legal arguments and considerations in Virginia that could potentially support your case:

Unlawful Detainer Stay: this is a legal action that can temporarily halt eviction proceedings. It's often used when there's a pending appeal or other legal actions that could affect the eviction.

Motion to Stay Unlawful Detainer Pending Federal Appeal: this motion can be filed to pause the eviction process while a federal appeal is being considered. It's different from a stay for modification, which seeks to change the terms of an existing order.

Motion to Reduce or Waive Escrow/Bond: this motion can request the court to lower or eliminate the bond amount required to stay the eviction. It's particularly relevant if the bond amount is unaffordable.

Motion to Dismiss Based on Pending Title Litigation: this motion argues that the eviction should be dismissed because there's ongoing litigation regarding the property's title, which could affect the eviction's validity.

Indigency/Fee Waiver: this is a request to waive court fees due to financial hardship. It's typically filed before other motions to ensure you're not burdened by costs.

Temporary Restraining Order (TRO) or Preliminary Injunction: these are legal tools that can prevent certain actions, like eviction, from occurring until a court can make a final decision. They're usually sought after an eviction has been ordered.

Legal Eagle

Let's break down your situation and the steps you can take:

Motion to Stay Unlawful Detainer Pending Federal Appeal — this motion is used to pause the eviction process while your federal appeal is being considered. It's different from a stay for modification, which seeks to change the terms of an existing order. You should file this motion if your appeal is still pending and you want to halt the eviction process. Virginia's appeal statute, Va. Code § 8.01-129, governs how an appeal from a general district court's unlawful detainer judgment is perfected in circuit court, including the timing and security requirements involved.
Motion to Reduce or Waive Escrow/Bond — if the bond amount is unaffordable, you can file this motion to request the court to lower or eliminate the bond required to stay the eviction. This is crucial if you cannot afford the $3,700 bond. Under Va. Code § 16.1-107, a defendant found to be indigent generally is not required to post an appeal bond, although unlawful detainer appeals involving a residential dwelling carry their own payment requirements tied to outstanding rent and related charges.
Motion to Dismiss Based on Pending Title Litigation — this motion argues that the eviction should be dismissed because there's ongoing litigation regarding the property's title. You would need to provide evidence of the pending title litigation to support this motion.
Indigency/Fee Waiver — file this request to waive court fees due to financial hardship. It's typically filed before other motions to ensure you're not burdened by costs. This can be done at the clerk's window before filing other motions. The indigency standard referenced in the bond statute above (Va. Code § 16.1-107) ties into the guidelines set out in Va. Code § 19.2-159 for determining eligibility.
Temporary Restraining Order (TRO) or Preliminary Injunction — these are legal tools that can prevent eviction from occurring until a court can make a final decision. They are usually sought after an eviction has been ordered, but you can inquire if it's applicable in your case. Since August 2024, Virginia circuit courts apply Rule 3:26 of the Rules of the Supreme Court of Virginia, which sets out the standard for granting a TRO or preliminary injunction, including the showing of irreparable harm required.
Communicate with Your Lawyer — it's important to discuss these motions with your interim lawyer, even if they initially said your motions wouldn't work. Explain your financial situation and the need for a payment plan that you can afford.

The interim lawyer said this: "No. None of those motions will be successful. The outcome was better than I could have anticipated. No bond for past rent due, and they wanted $6,000/month and got $3,700/day. The court already gave you a stay, which was a miracle in and of itself. The court will not reduce the bond or dismiss the UD. If there is some basis to ask, please let me know."

Legal Eagle

Thanks for sharing your lawyer's perspective. It sounds like they believe the current outcome is favorable given the circumstances. Could you tell me more about any specific reasons or evidence you might have that could support a motion to reduce the bond or dismiss the unlawful detainer? This could help in understanding if there's a basis to challenge the current situation.

The interim lawyer had filed a motion to dismiss and stay. In court, he mentioned the dismissal but focused on the stay, and the judge seemed unfamiliar with Parrish v. PHH Mortgage, a Supreme Court case. I have a live appeal that I filed myself. He would not file it, said I would lose. If I did not have that, I would have been evicted in the process on April 8th.

I am also a 76 year old senior with a mental health condition. I have lived in my home for 76 years. This case stems from a high conflict mortgage company that even 33 state attorneys general have filed against.

I am asking to modify the back rent amount of $3,700, but I am not a tenant, nor do I have a lease. I am the owner. The people who bought the house at auction went to a seminar on how to flip houses, and they are not even originally from the United States.

Anyway, the way it was done, it was as if it was constructed into an eviction.

Legal Eagle

Based on your situation, there are several legal arguments and considerations in Virginia that could potentially support your case:

Unlawful Detainer Stay: this is a legal action that can temporarily halt eviction proceedings. It's often used when there's a pending appeal or other legal actions that could affect the eviction.

Indigency/Fee Waiver: this is a request to waive court fees due to financial hardship. It's typically filed before other motions to ensure you're not burdened by costs.

I am confused. The $3,700 is the rental amount they are seeking, based on property values, not the condition of my home. The interim lawyer said the bond amount was supposedly waived. I have not looked at the paperwork online at the clerk's window yet. It was not posted as of last Friday.

Legal Eagle

I understand your confusion about the bond and rental amount. Let's break down your situation and the steps you can take:

Review Court Documents — first, check the court documents online or at the clerk's office to confirm the details about the bond and rental amount. This will give you a clear understanding of what has been decided.
Motion to Reduce or Waive Escrow/Bond — if the bond amount is unaffordable, you can file a motion to request the court to lower or eliminate the bond required to stay the eviction. This is crucial if you cannot afford the $3,700 bond.
Motion to Dismiss Based on Pending Title Litigation — this motion argues that the eviction should be dismissed because there's ongoing litigation regarding the property's title. You would need to provide evidence of the pending title litigation to support this motion.
Indigency/Fee Waiver — file this request to waive court fees due to financial hardship. It's typically filed before other motions to ensure you're not burdened by costs. This can be done at the clerk's window before filing other motions.
Temporary Restraining Order (TRO) or Preliminary Injunction — these are legal tools that can prevent eviction from occurring until a court can make a final decision. They are usually sought after an eviction has been ordered, but you can inquire if it's applicable in your case.
Communicate with Your Lawyer — it's important to discuss these motions with your interim lawyer, even if they initially said your motions wouldn't work. Explain your financial situation and the need for a payment plan that you can afford.

It is not a bond. The $3,700 is a monthly rental amount to stay in the house while the appeal is in process.

Legal Eagle

I hope I was able to help clarify your situation! If you have any other questions or need further assistance, feel free to ask.

I was clarifying that it is not a bond. The $3,700 is a monthly rental amount to stay in the house while the appeal is in process.

Legal Eagle

Understood! Please let me know if I can help you further. Thank you.

Thanks. I appreciate your educational knowledge.

Legal Eagle

You're very welcome! I'm glad I could help. If you have any more questions in the future, feel free to reach out. Take care!

I just texted my interim lawyer to file the motion to modify the amount, and he emailed back that even filing a motion to rehear would be meaningless and denied. I am so sad and afraid.

Legal Eagle

I'm really sorry to hear that you're feeling this way. It's understandable to feel sad and afraid in such a challenging situation. It might be helpful to seek a second opinion from another legal professional who can review your case and provide additional guidance. You could also reach out to local legal aid organizations that might offer support for seniors or those with disabilities. Remember, you're not alone in this, and there are people and resources that can help you navigate through these tough times. If you have any more questions or need further assistance, please feel free to ask.

Legal Eagle

135,460 satisfied customers

Criminal law, employment law, family law, landlord-tenant, and real estate law.

Welcome! Have a similar question?

By messaging AskALawyer, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy.

Clay G., Esq.

Attorney

4.66 (5,978)

[MN] Will an increase in income require a tenant to move out of Section 42 housing?

Answered 3 days ago

Angelo M

Managing Attorney, Juris Doctorate

4.58 (16,500)

[IL] Can a landlord require a tenant to leave during a routine inspection?

Answered 6 days ago

Liz

Lawyer

4.75 (46,810)

[NY] Can a co-owner evict a relative who moved into an inherited property without permission?

Answered 6 days ago

Disclaimer

By messaging AskaLawyer.com, you agree to our Terms and have read our Privacy Policy.

The information provided on AskaLawyer.com is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. While we strive to ensure the accuracy and timeliness of the information presented, we make no guarantees regarding its completeness or applicability to your specific circumstances.

Use of this website does not create an attorney-client relationship between you and AskaLawyer.com or any of its attorneys. Communications through this website, including any responses from attorneys, are not privileged or confidential. For advice tailored to your individual situation, we recommend consulting a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction.

AskaLawyer.com disclaims any liability for actions taken or not taken based on the content of this site. We are not responsible for any third-party content that may be accessed through this website. Reliance on any information provided herein is solely at your own risk.