[VA] Can a bankruptcy dismissal caused by a credit counseling certificate error be reopened years later?

VA Legal (General)

Jon

556 satisfied customers

View context

Solved

You can return to federal court by filing a Motion to Vacate Dismissal in the Alexandria Bankruptcy Court under Federal Rules of Civil Procedure Rule 60(b), which applies to bankruptcy cases through Federal Rule of Bankruptcy Procedure 9024. You must argue that the certificate timing was a clerical error or excusable neglect caused by your health, using your original receipt as proof of completion before filing.

While most mistake based claims must be filed within one year, you can argue for a reasonable time extension based on your circumstances. If the judge reopens the May 2024 case, it could retroactively apply the automatic stay under (11 U.S.C. § 362) to the date of your original filing, providing a legal path to challenge the foreclosure as a stay violation. Because this is your strongest remaining link to the property, you should act immediately and request specific accommodations for your speech and health conditions to ensure your evidence is properly considered by the court. But did that help clear things up for you? If you have any other questions or need more help, please don't hesitate to ask, I'm here to support you!

I do hope the information I provided was helpful and addressed your question. If there's anything else you need, please don't hesitate to reach out, I'm always happy to assist. Wishing you a fantastic day ahead!

Full Conversation

Bankruptcy Law and Procedures, Virginia.

Background: Am a senior in my 70s and attempted to do a bankruptcy in reality to ward off a wrongful foreclosure, and I thought to ease the aggression of build up of medical bills plus miscellaneous debt. I filed and did the basic paperwork and filed in person at the bankruptcy court in [address redacted] and I brought all the papers correctly and forms to the clerk's window in May 12th 2024, and in June 7th 2024 I had my first court appearance on it, and I was to include my credit counseling certificate, and it's the mandate, as you already know. Well, I took online the credit counseling, I paid for it with my debit card, yet they did not email me the certificate until 2 days later in my email. I did not think of it in detail, but when I went to court the judge said that the certificate shows I took it two days later than the due date required and before formal filing. I went alone without my niece or a friend, and I have a stuttering problem with a mental health condition. I tried to speak up and tell him that the receipt shows that I took it on that day, I did not pay for and then take the counseling and then get the certificate. He denied my bankruptcy filing. I had 10 days to appeal that, I do not remember why I did not appeal, I was so drained and overwhelmed and feeling alone, swallowed up from the system. Then the law firm that was managing the mortgage company accelerated the day of foreclosure date, they reapplied the process, for July 18th. But they moved the date up to August 21st and did not get a letter on that. Well, the house got foreclosed on wrongfully, and I have been fighting that battle still, overturning 2 eviction attempts, a lawsuit for one year and a half that got dismissed on a technicality due to my health and a missed deposition. It's now in appeal in the 4th Circuit Court.

Main question: it's still within the 2 year mark of that denied bankruptcy filing, I would have to do it by the first week of May to bring it to federal court. Can I bring a dispute or appeal to federal court or higher that the denied bankruptcy based on a computer clerical error is not rightful to proceed on that path? I read recently at a lobby room at the courthouse that was possible, and upon filing an appeal on that, if it is approved, it can revert back to when I filed in May 2024, and that would then have to reverse the action of that foreclosure law firm. Is that so? Can you guide me to the path of how I can salvage the past that was taken from me due to these chain of events.

Lexi, Chatbot

I'm sorry to hear about the overwhelming situation you've been facing with your bankruptcy and foreclosure. Have you already consulted with a bankruptcy lawyer regarding your denied filing and the potential appeal?

No, not a live one yet. Just now with this platform for the first time.

Lexi, Chatbot

Can you provide more details about any previous legal representation you had during your bankruptcy process or foreclosure proceedings?

Have had none.

Lexi, Chatbot

Is there anything else the bankruptcy lawyer should know before I connect you? Rest assured they'll be able to help with your denied bankruptcy.

You got everything.

Jon

Hello, and thank you for reaching out! I'm Jon, a licensed attorney with over 13 years of experience, here to help. I understand legal matters can feel overwhelming, but you're in good hands. My goal is to explain things clearly and guide you toward the best possible solution for your situation. Just a quick note, our conversation is for general legal information only and does not create an attorney-client relationship.

I understand you've been through a lot. Let's work through this together. Could you clarify if you have any documentation or evidence that supports your claim about the timing of the credit counseling certificate? This could be crucial in your appeal.

I have a copy of my receipt and the certificate they emailed only.

Jon

Could you tell me more about any legal actions or steps you've taken since the foreclosure, aside from the appeal in the 4th Circuit Court?

I understand this is a complex situation. Could you share if there have been any recent communications or updates from the foreclosure law firm or the court regarding your case?

No other steps except trying to prevent the eviction process that is being imposed on me again in the General District Court. I have an interim attorney that did the lawsuit and is the same person from last year that prevented the eviction last year based on the filing that was brought to the Circuit Court that led to the federal court filing for the lawsuit. When my case was shockingly dismissed, they became bitter and disrespectful because I did not show up due to a deposition order, and I was ill, and said they would not represent me on a motion to rehear and or file the appeal. I did it myself with help of my niece, and though he said he would do the unlawful detainer, instead of doing what I asked, to have the eviction process dismissed from the General District Court for res judicata, he said no and led me to a stay process that is a construct to eviction.

Jon

Thank you for sharing that information. It sounds like you've been through a lot with your interim attorney and the eviction process. Could you clarify when the foreclosure initially took place and when your appeal in the 4th Circuit Court was filed? This will help me understand the timeline better.

No, no communications. They are aware that I am in appeal.

Jon

Understood! I believe I have all the information I need. Is there anything else you'd like to add before I start working on your answer? If not, I'll get started right away.

They were on the lawsuit paperwork for pushing the foreclosure process after my bankruptcy did not go through.

Jon

Got it! I just need a few minutes to put together a complete response for you. It shouldn't take longer than about 4 to 5 minutes, and I want to make sure it's clear and comprehensive. Thanks so much for waiting, I really appreciate your patience.

Please start answer. Logical, factual order and steps for me to take to win back what was taken from me unethically.

Jon

Under 11 U.S.C. § 109(h), you have to complete credit counseling before filing your bankruptcy petition. The court treats this as a basic eligibility requirement. If the record shows the counseling was completed after filing, even due to a clerical issue, the court can treat the case as invalid from the start, calling it a jurisdictional defect. Appealing that dismissal is also tightly time limited. Under Rule 8002, you generally have 14 days to appeal. Since your case was dismissed in June 2024, that window has long passed.

There is a possible fallback under Rule 60(b), which allows relief from a judgment based on mistake or excusable neglect, but most of those arguments must be raised within 1 year. Trying to reopen things nearly 2 years later is very difficult unless there's something extreme, like fraud on the court. As for undoing the foreclosure, there is a legal theory that if a dismissal is reversed, the automatic stay could be treated as if it never lapsed. But in reality, once the property has been sold, especially to a good faith third party buyer, courts are very unlikely to reverse that sale. At that point, the legal system tends to protect the finality of the transaction unless there was a clear violation of the stay or a serious defect in the foreclosure process.

Right now, your focus is the eviction case. In Virginia General District Court, you can argue that the court should not proceed if there's still an active appeal in a higher court that affects ownership of the property. This ties into res judicata and subject matter jurisdiction, essentially, you're saying the lower court should wait until the higher court decides who actually has the right to the property. Your Fourth Circuit appeal is the key piece. Make sure it's still active and that all deadlines have been met. If your earlier case was dismissed because of something like a missed deposition tied to your health, that's where excusable neglect becomes important, especially if you have medical documentation. You also have the right to request accommodations under Title II of the Americans with Disabilities Act. That can include extra time, assistance during hearings, or adjustments to how proceedings are handled so you can fully participate. At this stage, it's important to stay on top of your appeal, bring proof of it to your eviction hearing, and ask the court to pause enforcement while the higher court case is pending. You can also request to proceed in forma pauperis if filing fees are a barrier. The hard truth is that once a foreclosure sale has gone through, undoing it is much harder than stopping it beforehand. Most paths forward focus on whether there were legal violations that could lead to damages or limited relief, rather than fully reversing the sale. A bankruptcy or foreclosure litigation attorney may be able to spot a narrow angle based on the specific details of that clerical error.

I thought I did ask for a bankruptcy litigation attorney here. So, I am asking if I can take it to federal court, the unjust denial of bankruptcy due to a clerical error done in May 2024. That there is no statute of limitations if my civil liberties were abused or denied during bankruptcy.

Jon

I am. However, there are no lawyers here for hire, as this is only Q&A.

Jon

So, I am asking if I can take it to federal court, the unjust denial of bankruptcy due to a clerical error done in May 2024. That there is no statute of limitations if my civil liberties were abused or denied during bankruptcy.

Jon

You can return to federal court by filing a Motion to Vacate Dismissal in the Alexandria Bankruptcy Court under Rule 60(b). You must argue that the certificate timing was a clerical error or excusable neglect caused by your health, using your original receipt as proof of completion before filing. While most mistake based claims must be filed within one year, you can argue for a reasonable time extension based on your circumstances. If the judge reopens the May 2024 case, it could retroactively apply the automatic stay to the date of your original filing, providing a legal path to challenge the foreclosure as a stay violation. Because this is your strongest remaining link to the property, you should act immediately and request specific accommodations for your speech and health conditions to ensure your evidence is properly considered by the court.

Jon

556 satisfied customers

Welcome! Have a similar question?

By messaging AskALawyer, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy.

Phil (Immigration Phil)

Attorney

4.65 (3,651)

[VA] How can you ask a federal court to correct inaccurate information in the case record?

Answered 1 hour ago

Lawyer, Esquire

Attorney at Law

5.00 (25)

[CA] Can a former attorney still enforce a fee lien after withdrawing without cause?

Answered 3 hours ago

Andrew F., Esq.

Expert

4.26 (42)

What does an FDCPA lawsuit need to allege to survive dismissal and support a settlement?

Answered 4 days ago

Disclaimer

By messaging AskaLawyer.com, you agree to our Terms and have read our Privacy Policy.

The information provided on AskaLawyer.com is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. While we strive to ensure the accuracy and timeliness of the information presented, we make no guarantees regarding its completeness or applicability to your specific circumstances.

Use of this website does not create an attorney-client relationship between you and AskaLawyer.com or any of its attorneys. Communications through this website, including any responses from attorneys, are not privileged or confidential. For advice tailored to your individual situation, we recommend consulting a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction.

AskaLawyer.com disclaims any liability for actions taken or not taken based on the content of this site. We are not responsible for any third-party content that may be accessed through this website. Reliance on any information provided herein is solely at your own risk.